October 9-12, 2002 |
|||||
Appendix I: LIST OF KOREAN PARTICIPANTSAppendix II: AgendaAppendix III: CONCLUSION |
|||||
Summary Report |
|||||
| As an outcome of the 1st Korea-U.S. Joint Coordination Meeting (JCM) for Aquaculture Cooperation held in Busan, Republic of Korea, April 15-16, 2002, the Korea-U.S. Meeting for Scientific and Technical Cooperation in the Fields of Polyculture and Offshore Aquaculture Technology was convened in Honolulu, Hawaii, USA, October 9-12, 2002. The meeting helped define joint research projects and corresponding timelines focused on advancing scientific and technological knowledge in the two areas of aquaculture between the two countries. Dr. Yoon Kim, Director of the Aquaculture Department of the National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (NFRDI) under the Ministry of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries (MOMAF), and Dr. James McVey, Aquaculture Program Director for the National Sea Grant College Program, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), U.S. Department of Commerce, co-chaired the meeting. Twenty eight (28) U.S. (five representatives from federal government, a representative of the Hawaii State Government, thirteen representatives from academia, four representatives from private research organizations, and five representatives from industry) and nine (9) Korean (two representatives from national government, four representatives from research organizations, and three representatives from academia) delegates participated in this meeting. (see attached list of participants in Appendix I). | |||||
| Dialogue between the delegates was excellent not only during the two day substantive meeting but also, through several field trips to the Oceanic Institute, the Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology, and Cates International, Inc. (see attached agenda in Appendix II). The meeting provided a timely and important venue for both countries to exchange scientific knowledge and ideas on pursuing sustainable aquaculture by promoting new concepts of integrated culture systems including coastal modeling to manage such systems. The components of such systems include algae, filter feeders and other ecological function groups to reduce the aesthetic and environmental problems of nearshore aquaculture by developing more efficient and effective submerged cage culture in the open-ocean in Korea and the United States. | |||||
| In conventional coastal aquaculture conditions, environmental problems have developed in some areas because of nutrient loading that overwhelms the carrying capacity of the dynamic water systems along the more shallow coastlines. During the meeting, it was agreed that the new offshore aquaculture approach constitutes a paradigm shift from the present systems used in world aquaculture. The concept of using aquaculture to place natural biological and ecological functions in coastal ecosystems is just beginning to be explored in both the Korean and US research communities. This new approach requires definition of the ecological function of the biota found in coastal ecosystems and the development of models including the biological, environmental and hydrographic components of coastal ecosystems. | |||||
| Two types of aquaculture have been practiced in the world: 1) ¡®extractive aquaculture¡¯ of species that provide filtration or absorption of nutrients and 2) ¡®fed aquaculture¡¯ of high value species that require the introduction of food to the species being cultured. The participants agreed to cooperate in developing the scientific base for exploring the concepts of moving ¡°fed aquaculture¡± to more offshore locations with greater carrying capacity for nutrients. Also, both countries shared an understanding that using polyculture concepts to place integrated ecological function in coastal and offshore ecosystems would be a balanced ecosystem approach to aquaculture. | |||||
| Throughout both the group break-out session and the full group meeting, the participants agreed to cooperate in the two separate areas of polyculture and offshore aquaculture technology, and to include nutrient flow and ecosystem modeling to tie these concepts together. Also, the participants agreed to move ahead in developing further ideas, seeking available financial sources, and prioritizing action items and timeline identified in Appendix III. | |||||
Appendix I
LIST OF KOREAN PARTICIPANTS(Alphabetical) |
|||||
Ik Kyo Chung |
Qtae Jo |
||||
Sung-Ho Joo |
Yoon Kim |
||||
Taeho Kim |
Shin-Chul Park |
||||
Cheongro Ryu |
Jang-Taek Yoon |
||||
Jin-Man Kim (observer) |
|||||
LIST OF U.S. PARTICIPANTS(Alphabetical) |
|||||
Daniel D. Benetti |
Christopher Bridger |
||||
John Randy Cates |
Barbaros Celikkol |
||||
John Corbin |
John Curtis |
||||
Mark Drawbridge |
Virginia Enos |
||||
Rene Eppi |
David Fredriksson |
||||
Langley Gace |
Charles Helsley |
||||
Dosoo Jang |
Richard Langan |
||||
Cheng-Sheng Lee |
Jo-Ann Leong |
||||
James P. McVey |
Eileen McVey |
||||
Paul Olin |
Mac Rawson |
||||
Michael Rust |
Robin Shields |
||||
Neil Anthony Sims |
Clyde Tamaru |
||||
David Vaughan |
Charles Yarish |
||||
Gary Loverich |
James J. Sullivan |
||||
Appendix II Korea-U.S. Meeting for Scientific and Technical Cooperation
|
|||||
SCHEDULE/AGENDA |
|||||
Tuesday, October 8, 2002 09:50 Korean participants arrive in Honolulu via Delta #7115 operated by Korean AirAfternoon U.S. participants arrive in Honolulu Hotel: The New Otani Kaimana Beach Hotel 19:00 Welcome reception Wednesday, October 9, 2002 Thursday, October 10, 2002 PART I: OPENING09:00 Welcome and introduction (Meeting Room: Yukiyoshi Room, University of Hawaii) James Mcvey, U.S. Chairperson/NOAA Yoon Kim, Korean Chairperson/NFRDI PART II: PRESENTATIONS 09:30 Presentations of mutual interests in the area of polyculture Facilitator : Jo-Ann Leong, Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology Facilitator: Richard Langan, University of New Hampshire Charles Helsley University of Hawaii (emeritus) 12:00 Lunch
John Randy Cates Cates International, LLC Johh Corbin Hawaii State Government Mark Drawbridge Hubbs Sea World Research Institute Virginia Enos Cates International, LLC Rene Eppi NOAA David Fredriksson University of New Hampshire Langley Gace Net Systems, Inc Jin Man Kim Yosu University Taeho Kim NFRDI Yoon Kim NFRDI Richard Langan University of New Hampshire Gary Loverich The Net Systems, Inc. Cheng-Sheng Lee The Oceanic Institute Jo-Ann Leong Hawaii Institute of Marine Biology Eileen McVey NOAA Paul Olin University of California Sea Grant Shin-Chul Park MOMAF Michael Rust NOAA Robin Shields The Oceanic Institute Clyde Tamaru University of Hawaii Sea Grant 10:20 Coffee break 10:40 Full Group Meeting for Justification Facilitators: Yoon Kim and James McVey 12:00 Lunch (Location: Room 203E, Campus Center, University of Hawaii) 13:30 Write up the group meeting summaries 14:30 Presentations on the group meeting conclusions/summaries Facilitators: Yoon Kim and James McVey Group (A) Facilitators (maximum 15 minutes) Group (B) Facilitators (maximum 15 minutes) 15:30 Coffee break PART IV: WRAP-UP SESSION Facilitators: Yoon Kim and James McVey 15:50 Creation of the U.S.-Korea Aquauculture Data and Information Website Eileen McVey 16:00 Discussion of timetable and action items 17:00 Adjourn 19:00 Dinner hosted by Korean delegation Saturday, October 12, 2002 08:30 Depart hotel to Cates International, Inc.¡¯s offshore aquaculture site 12:00 Lunch A post-field trip roundtable discussion Facilitator: John Randy Cates, Cates International, Inc. 14:00 Adjourn 18:00 Moi fry BBQ hosted by Cates International, Inc.
|
|||||
Appendix IIICONCLUSIONA. Offshore Aquaculture Technology Group During the break-out session, the Offshore Aquaculture Technology Group identified several key areas/components requiring specific attention through research and commercial demonstration. These areas have been listed below in no specific priority area:Site selection criteria Bottom topography/sediment type/depth Logistics/access (infrastructure) Arrangement of site components System requirements Feed delivery to system, in particular submerged cagesControlled harvesting, incremental harvesting Size grading requirements followed by selective harvesting Biofouling control (including anti-foulants; net cleaner (robotics)) Divers¡¯ health management Monitoring systems (including environment, facility security/management) Containment Fish transport and acclimation Logistical support and vessel design Large scale demonstration Biological considerations Species selection and diversityGenetic management Stock identification and tagging development Stocking sizes and technologies Nutrition/feed requirements -fish meal reduction -diversification -by-product utilization Fish health management/fish disease diagnosis and control Fish quality Human health feed health assurance/positive components Hatchery technology and species availability Polyculture Reproductive management Biological interactions/habitat enrichment/optimization Species behavior and modification and cage design to optimize Environmental considerations Nutrient enrichment of water column (pros and cons) Organic enrichment of sediment Biological interactions -fish aggregating devices (FADs), marine mammals, as habitat enhancement Ecological interactions (escapees and disease transfer) Impacts of human origin Feed composition (raw feeds vs. extruded feeds) Seed stock source Medications and vaccines Development of a Code of Conduct and a best management plan (BMP) Risk assessment Markets and economics Exchange of production statistics in fisheries and aquacultureMarket size/product selection/species Value-added/product form Consumer preference Scale of production Education and outreach Public perception Regulatory considerations Size of fish regulated by wild harvests B. Polyculture and Modeling Group (Working group to include but not restrictive to: New England Integrated Aquaculture Team-UConn, UNH, SUNY, UMe, BRVAS; the Northwest Fisheries Science Center, NMFS, NOAA, UW, WSU, OSU; National Fishery Research and Development Institute (NFRDI); Pusan National University; and Pukyong National University; University of Georgia and UMass-Dartmouth ) During the group break-out session, the attendees of the polyculture and modeling group discussed several key areas, components, and timelines to begin active cooperation in the areas of polyculture identified below.Develop land-based model
***Commence: April 2003 and draft model made available by December 2003. Establish a follow-up workshop With specific parameters to be determined for input into the selected model (Key species, demonstration sites,identification of data gaps and needed research and scale of activities to be products of the workshop) ***Expected completion: April 2003 Identification of sites (Korea and the US) ***Expected completion: May 2003 Implementation of preliminary land-based model ***Commence: January 2004 and draft to be available by January 2005 Monitor/manipulate land-based model To begin the development of a near-shore model for aquaculture area(s)***Commence: Near-shore monitoring effort (in Korea) in 2003 and continue effort through 2005 Develop the offshore model
possible candidate species for integrated aquaculture programs. Restoration of coastal habitats
Education component
Development of instructional modules/processes at Bridgeport Regional Vocational School in Connecticut to deliver to students at Wando Fisheries High School in Korea through student exchanges and distance learning ***Commence: Between spring-fall 2003 KOREA-U.S. PRIORITIES/TIMELINE RELATIVE TO OFFSHORE AQUACULTURE TECHNOLOGY Following a general discussion made during the break-out session regarding the issues associated with open-ocean aquaculture industry development, the Offshore Aquaculture Technology Group prioritized the issues for installing an open-ocean demonstration operation (mainly from the Korean perspective):Site selection -Identify existing oceanographic, geological and biological data-Conduct a site specific survey for selecting sites for grow-out ***Expected completion: March 2003 Species selection based on market and technology -Korean spp includes cod, yellowtail, (sea bream, sea bass)-US spp include cod, greater amberjack, rockfish -Bilateral scientific exchange (potential involvement from Mike Rust, Mark Drawbridge) ***Korea: Species selection: Expected completion: March 2003 ***U.S.: Provide recommendation for potential operation experience through scientific exchange to operating US sites. Seed production and transport -Improvement of technology (including increasing scale of production)-Species specific with site condition ***Expected completion: May-July 2003 System design and management -Open-ocean cage construction techniques (with assistance of Net Systems, Inc.)***Expected completion: July 2003 -Dive safety and operation protocol ***Expected completion: July/2003 -Feeding system (requiring additional research attention) ***Commence: April 2003 Remote monitoring system -Feed/environmental/total monitoring/fish movement ***Commence: As soon as the open-cage system is launched underwater Standardized data collection Model nutrient and organic fate/flow (including land-based experimentation) -Identification of appropriate researchers and institutions to work together with such modeling and demonstration projects from both the U.S. and KoreaTechnician training and student exchange programs -Include possible corporate interaction ***Commence: April 2003 Creation and distribution of extension manuals to fishermen ***Commence: After the first open-ocean cage is put underwater 2nd Korea-U.S. Joint Coordination Meeting for Aquaculture Cooperation on Site ***Expected date: Between summer 2003-spring 2004
|
|||||