Third U.S.-China Joint Coordination Panel on Living Marine Resources

March 11-14, 1997
Silver Spring, Maryland, U.S.A.

Table of Contents

  1. Minute
  2. Work Plan for 1997-1998
  3. Delegation

1. The Minutes

In accordance with the Minutes of the Second U.S.-China Living Marine Resources Joint Coordination Panel Meeting and as agreed by the two sides, the Third Meeting of U.S.-China Living Marine Resources Joint Coordination Panel ( hereafter referred to as "Third LMRJCP") was held in Silver Spring, Maryland U.S.A. from March 11-14, 1997. Dr. James Paul McVey, National Aquaculture Director, National Sea Grant College Program of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration led the U.S. delegation; Professor Qian Zhilin, President of the Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences, led the Chinese delegation. The meeting was co-chaired by the heads of the two delegations.

Dr. McVey delivered opening remarks, extending warm welcome to the Chinese delegation, and Congratulations on the holding of the Third LMRJCP Meeting in Silver Spring. Dr. McVey welcomed Professor Qian as new Chairman of the Chinese delegation and expressed appreciation on the hard work of Mr. Liu Congmeng as previous delegation co-Chair. Professor Qian expressed appreciation for holding the Third Panel Meeting in Silver Spring and his pleasure to lead the Chinese delegation to this meeting to discuss cooperation in an area of great importance. Both delegations and participants exchanged brief introductions. The agenda was discussed and agreed.

During the meeting, both sides began with a review of the status of projects under the Second LMRJCP Meeting Minutes and shared a high degree of satisfaction with the progress of activities.

Both sides affirmed various matters of principle for continued U.S.-China cooperation in the field of living marine resources. The primary objective of collaboration under this forum is the promotion of mutual interests and exchanges in science, research, training in aquaculture, fisheries and related areas between the two countries. The dissemination of research results through peer reviewed publications in professional journals is a desired outcome both as product of collaboration and to promote awareness of the importance of U.S.-China cooperation in this area. Continued collaboration and contact between principal investigators and colleagues following specific exchange activities, is desired. Both sides agreed to work together creatively identify funding channels to further promote and expand both the breadth and scope of cooperation between fisheries and aquacultural scientists of both counties. Additional funding channels could include non-government, multilateral, other governmental, and private sector grants in addition to traditional funding mechanisms. Finally, to dedicate increased attention on program activities, both sides agreed to meet approximately every two years to develop a work plan of two years duration.

The two sides emphasized that the objective for the work of U.S.-China LMRJCP is to establish an efficient working mechanism and further intensify the broad cooperation and exchanges in the fields of marine and fishery science between the two countries through the identification and implementation of cooperative projects.

The two sides reiterated that equality, mutual benefit, common development and seeking common ground while preserving differences are basic principles underlining cooperation. Both sides agreed to proceed step by step in carrying out the cooperation in a spirit of openness and full exchange of information.

The two sides agreed that the Third LMRJCP meeting would discuss those priority projects in which common interest exists and could be implemented within available and projected resources of each country. Discussions covered Aquaculture Techniques and Science, Environmental Assessments of Aquaculture and Fisheries, and Personnel Exchange and Training. With regard to those projects for which there desire for implementation could not be guaranteed during the four day meetings owing to various issues such as budget, logistics, scheduling, or other issues and circumstances, those projects are also submitted for implementation, as possible. Both sides intend to implement all projects identified.

The two sides also agreed that in principle, for the projects identified by the LMRJCP, unless clearly indicated otherwise, the sending side will cover the international traveling expenses and receiving side will cover the local expenses for food, accommodation and transportation in their country. Transportation from national port of entry to local work location would be addressed on a case-by-case basis. Both sides are agree to make full use of their relative strengths to develop a complementary program, taking full advantages of resources, technology, and funds.

In order to ensure sufficient time for preparation for project implementation, the sending side and receiving side will aim to confirm through dialogue exact dates and specific project requirements 30 to 45 days prior to commencement of joint activities.

The Third LMRJCP concluded with recommendation for the implementation of projects for the 1997 and 1998 period. Both sides agree to work with vigor towards their successful implementation subject to availability of funds within this period in accordance with the budgetary process. Additional projects will continue to be discussed for future implementation. The implementation plan of the identified projects at the meeting will be worked out through detailed discussion between the Co-Chairman and the implementing institutions of both sides.

The Panel reaffirms that it needs to continue to meet to facilitate U.S.-china cooperative activities under the U.S.-China Marine and Fisheries Protocol of the U.S.-china Science and Technology Agreement. The Chinese delegation agreed to host the Fourth LMRJCP meeting in the People's Republic of China in late 1998 or early 1999. The detailed schedule and venue will be finalized by the Co-Chairman of the LMRJCP through correspondence.

The Minutes are signed in Silver Spring, Maryland on March 14, 1997, in duplicate in English and Chinese, both texts being equally authentic.
Dr. James P. McVey Professor Qian Zhilin
National Aquaculture Coordinator President
National Sea Grant College Program Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

2. The Work Plan for 1997-1998

  1. Shrimp
    1. Endocrinology of Shrimp Reproduction, Maturation, and Spawning in Penaeus chinensis
      Dr. Hans Laufer will travel to China tentatively in May or June 1997 for one to two weeks to assess and prepare conditions for collaboration on this topic. China will send one principal investigator to the United States to collaborate with Dr. Hans Laufer for up to six months in late 1997 to early 1998.
      US Principal Investigator: University of Connecticut, Hans Laufer
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Institute of Oceanology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Li Fuhua
    2. Shrimp Virology
      One Chinese scientist will travel to the United States for up to 6 months, tentatively scheduled for late November to June 1998 for continuation of this project from First and Second work plans.
      US Principal Investigator: University of Arizona, Dr. Donald Lightner
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Yellow Sea Fishery Research Institute,CAFS, Mr. Huang Jie
    3. Introduction o SPF Shrimp Seed
      A program will be pursued incorporating expertise in the United States and China in the issues of introduction of SPF shrimp ( Penaeus vannamei) seed, quarantine technology, and development of nucleus breeding center. The Panel recognized the importance of this issue but could not confirm specific implementation activities during the course of the meeting.
      US Principal Investigating Institution: Gulf Coast Research Laboratory Consortium
      Chinese Principal Investigating Institution: Yellow Sea Fishery Research Institute, CAFS
    4. Study on the Molecular Biology of Shrimp Baculovirus
      One US scientist is invited to China in 1997 to begin coordinating this project. One Chinese scientist is invited to the United States for three months in 1997 and 1998.
      US Principal Institution: to be determined
      Chinese Principal Institution: Third Institute of Oceanography, SOA, Xu Xun
    5. Sustainable Shrimp Aquaculture
      Continuation of Education Program for Gong Hui and Jiang Donghuo of Qingdao on shrimp nutrition and feed research for the development of environmentally friendly feeds and pond management. Also, a model for pond production and environmental impact will be developed for use in sustainable aquaculture and fisheries.
      US Principal Investigator: Dr. Addison Lawrence, Texas A& M University
      Implementation schedule: continuing
  2. Shellfish
    1. Chromosome Manipulation in Shellfish
      Continuation of work defined previously and started with Second LMR Report. One Chinese scientist will travel to the United States in 1997-1998 for up to six months.
      US Principal Investigator: Rutgers University, Stan Allen
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Institute of Oceanology, Zhang Fusui
    2. Survey of Chinese Production and Research of Shellfish culture
      One US scientist will travel to China to discuss, observe, and document the extent and nature of recent developments in Chinese molluscan industry in September 1-30, 1997 or April 1-30, 1998
      US Principal Investigator: Rutgers University, Ximing Guo
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Institute of Oceanology, Zhang Fusui
    3. Disease
      To continue collaborative work in Bay Scallop disease begun in 1993 and to understand the distribution and pathogenicity of the unidentified haplosporidian parasite found in scallop samples in Shandong and Liaoning Provinces, two US shellfish pathologists will travel to China in 1998 for three weeks to define protocol and training for sampling shellfish for joint study at VIMS in 1999.
      US Principal Investigator: Virginia Institute of Marines Sciences, Fu Lin Chu and Eugene Burreson
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Institute of Oceanology, Zhang Fusui
    4. Shellfish Disease Diagnostic Technique Research
      Arrangements will be begun for one Chinese scientist to travel to the United States Virginia Institute of Marine Sciences in 1999 for up to six months to continue collaboration on disease research under 2 above.
      US Principle Investigators: Virginia Institute of Marine Sciences, Fu Lin Chu and Eugene Burreson
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Institute of Oceanology, Zhang Fusui
  3. Aquaculture Education Exchange
    1. Visit by three representatives of the Bridgeport Aquaculture High School to the Shanghai Fisheries University in Spring 1997 to review and discuss Chinese curriculum in aquaculture and potential topics areas such as eel culture, flounder fish, or other areas to be identified of mutual interest for approximately two weeks.
    2. Visit to United States by one expert to translate and develop aquaculture curriculum at Bridgeport High School from September 1997 to January or February 1998.
    3. Visit to United States by one aquaculture expert in area identified in activity (a) above as an instructor/researcher at Bridgeport Aquaculture High School from September 1997 to September 1998.
    4. Development of distance learning facilities and capabilities between the Bridgeport Aquaculture High School and NOAA for the United States and the Shanghai Fisheries University and other representatives to be identified for China. This effort may involve offer by Bridgeport Aquaculture for provision of computer facility to Shanghai Fisheries University, if needed.
      US Participants: Bridgeport Aquaculture High School and NOAA
      Dates: to be defined
  4. Finfish
    1. Finfish Introduction, Training, Exchange Program
      Building upon exchanges implemented under the Second Living Marine Resources program and mutual interest between specific US and Chinese institutions in this area, a formalized program will be developed between Oceanic Institute and the South China Sea Fishery Research Institute in the area of finfish cooperation. Exchanges concerning mullet, common Dolphin, rotifer, and other finfish-related issues will be discussed and implemented following correspondence of the Co-Chairman and heads of the two identified national institutions. Agreement for specific activities will be based upon mutual interest of both institutions. This effort encourages continuation of mullet cooperation project begun with Second LMR Report pending further discussions. Both sides agree to proceed with the exchange of information concerning finfish development in their respective countries to further calcify mutual interests for a sustained program in finfish aquaculture.
      US Principal Institution: The Oceanic Institute
      Chinese Principal Institution: South China Sea Fishery Research Institute, CAFS
    2. Viral Disease in Finfish
      Short-term visit to China by US viral disease specialist in 1997/1998 to learn state of viral disease of fish in China, the discuss needs of Chinese and US researchers in this area for joint collaboration, explore possibilities for specific collaborative research efforts for mutual benefit, and explore possibilities for Chinese students to come to the United States to pursue M.S. and Ph.D degrees in antigenic variation of aquatic birnaviruses and other areas including technology transfer, opportunities for PCR and DNA sequencing studies, and exploration of new aquaculture species in the US, such as tilapia.
      US Principal Investigator: University of Maine, Bruce Nicholson
      Chinese Principal Investigator: to be determined
    3. Spotted Sea Trout
      One or two US scientists are invited to the First Institute of Oceanography in Qingdao in 1997 for continuation of program begun under Second LMR Report.
      US Principal Investigator: Texas Parks and Wildlife, Robert Vga
      Chinese Principal Investigator: First Institute of Oceanography, Mao Xinghua
  5. Algae
    1. Porphyra cultivation techniques
      In accordance with activities in this area under the LMR forum and the Memorandum of Agreement between the Biotechnology Center of the University of Connecticut and the Experimental Marine Biology Laboratory of the Institute of Oceanology of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, one US scientist will travel to China in Fall 1997 to learn and observe the latest developments in Chinese advances primarily at the Chinese Academy of Sciences in this area and a subsequent 3 month visit by a Chinese scientist to develop a prototype nori farm for enhanced nutrient removal by native American species and assistance improving genetic manipulation of the conchocelis "seed."
      US Principal Investigator: Charles Yarish, University of Connecticut
      Chinese Principal Investigator: Fei Xiugeng, Institute of Oceanology
    2. Harmful Algal Blooms
      This project will be continued from the Second Living Marine Resources Joint Coordination Panel (previously red tide). Subject priorities to be addressed include 1) laboratory cultivation of HAB samples, 2) toxicity analysis, and 3)
      US Principal Investigator: to be clarified
      Chinese Principal Investigator: First Institute of Oceanography, Zhu Mingyuan
  6. Jiaozhou Bay Project
    Understanding carrying capacity, species interactions, and biodiversity remains a high priority theme of the U.S.-China Living Marine Resources Panel. Development of an ecosystem model with simulation capability of the lower and high trophic level food web interactions in Jiaozhou Bay is continuing. The model being developed would examine effects of physical and chemical environments on the resource production, such as shrimp, scallop, and seaweed. To promote continued advances in addressing theoretical, modeling and data requirements, US and Chinese principal investigators agreed to expand the Jiaozhou Bay modeling effort to incorporate resources and expertise of additional partners, including the Institute of Oceanology in Qingdao, the Ocean University of Qingdao, and the University of Georgia. Specific activities in this project will be identified and coordinated between co-team leads through correspondence.
    US Principal Investigator: National Marine Fisheries Service, Loh Lee Low
    US Supporting Investigators: University of Washington, Vincent Galucci; University of Georgia, Changsheng Chen
    Chinese Principal Investigator: First Institute of Oceanography, Zhu Mingyuan; Chinese Supporting Investigators: Institute of Oceanology
  7. Fisheries Conservation and By-Catch Reduction
    By-catch reduction is an important conservation and resource utilization issue. The University of Georgia has been involved in research and technology development and transfer designed to reduce by-catch. The US side proposes broadening bilateral discussions to ecosystem issues and bringing a team of NOAA (Sea Grant, Environmental Research Laboratory, and National Marine Fisheries Service) experts to China to develop a project plan in line with US and Chinese interests in this common area as reflected in related project proposals. Successful bilateral U.S.-China cooperation in this area could improve the productivity of near shore ocean environments and provide a scientific basis for future fisheries conservation and interest requiring further discussion of specific activities following the Third LMRJCP Meeting. This project should include both laboratory research and field work.
    US Principal Investigator: University of Georgia, Dr. Mac Rawson and other US Investigators to be identified
    Chinese Principal Investigator: East China Sea Fishery Research Institute and other institutions to be identified
  8. Data and Information
    Mr. Yang Ningsheng of the Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences will travel to the United States in Spring 1997 for a period of four months to establish a mechanism and program for the sustained exchange of fisheries, aquaculture, and related research and statistical data between China and the United States. Both sides place highest priority on this project.
    US Principal Investigator: NOAA Library, Carol Watts
    Chinese Principal Investigator: Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences, Yang Ningsheng

3. The Delegation

Chinese Delegation

Prof. Qian Zhilin
P.R.C. CO-Chair LMR Panel
President, Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences

Prof. Liu Ruiyu
Professor, Institute of Oceanology
Chinese Academy of Sciences

Prof. Zhu Mingyuan
Professor, First Institute of Oceanography
State Oceanic Administration

Ms. Wang Qin
Interpreter
Chinese Academy of Fishery Sciences

US Delegation

Dr. Standish Allen
Associate Professor, Rutgers University

Dr. M. Robert Belas
Center of Marine Biotechnology
Baltimore, Maryland

Dr. Anthony Calabrese
Director, Milford Laboratory
NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service

Dr. Chansheng Chen
Assistant Professor, University of Georgia

Dr. Kenneth Chew
Director-School of Fisheries
University of Washington

Dr. Fu Lin Chu
College of William & Mary
Virginia Institute of Marine Sciences

Mr. James A. Cnnelly
Superintendent of Schools
Bridgeport, Connecticut

Dr. Ximing Guo
Assistant Professor, Rutgers University

Mr. Jonathan Justi
U.S. Executive Secretary
NOAA, Office of the Under Secretary

Dr. Addison Lawrence
Professor, Texas A&M University

Dr. Hans Laufer
Professor, University of Connecticut

Dr. Loh-lee Low
Deputy Derector-Resources Ecology & Fishery Management
NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service

Dr. James McVey
U.S. Co-Chair, LMR Panel
National Aquaculture Coordinator
NOAA National Sea Grant College Program

Dr. Mac Rawson
Director, Georgia Sea Grant Program
Department of Marine Sciences, University of Georgia

Dr. Steven Waste
Aquaculture Coordinator
National Marine Fisheries Service
Office of Sustainable Fisheries

Dr. Kenneth Webb
College of William & Mary
Viginia Institute of Marine Sciences

Mr. Mark Wildman
Office of International Affairs
NOAA National Marine Fisheries Service

Dr. Charles Yarish
Professor, University of Connectitut

Dr. Cheng Sheng Lee
Director, The Oceanic Institute

Mr. John J. Curtis
Supervisor
Bridgeport Aquaculture School
Back to China Home Page